Culture, Cultural Variations, Culture Shock, Ethnocentrism, and Cultural Relativity: Understanding Across Difference: In this assignment, I want to get you to look into CULTURAL VARIATION, the CULTURE SHOCK that may come next, the ETHNOCENTRIMS that subjectively attempts to answer questions about the variations, and the need for CULTURAL RELATIVISM to get to a more sociological and objective view of the variations. Some background “notes” to review and consider before you follow thru on what I’m asking for in this assignment: How we perceive and deal with CULTURAL VARIATION is not only important, but follows patterns with labels for concepts that describe what goes on along the way. It has always fascinated sociologists and anthropologists how we HAVE cultural variations and how we DEAL with them coming from others. In lecture/ class, I have started in on WHAT Culture is and WHAT role it plays in our lives. I’ve also started in on HOW Culture becomes a filter for how we SEE each other and each other’s Culture. We are going to review the FIVE overall components of a viable culture (1. tools, 2. beliefs, 3. norms, 4. values & 5. Language) and their combined cultural expressions. Note that cultural variations will appear in the five cultural components of So it is in these areas that we can explore cultural variations. Here’s how the responses to cultural variations line up … Cultural Variation à Culture Shock Culture shock à The strain that people from one culture experience when they must reorient themselves sto the ways of a new culture. * Cultural Shock leads to attempts to ask questions and arrive at answers. This takes a subjective stop along the way with … Culture Shock à Ethnocentrism Ethnocentrism/Ethnocentricityà a viewpoint that uses one culture, usually the home culture (or when occurring WITHIN a society, this is the dominant/larger culture), as the standard for judging the worth of foreign ways (or, again, when occurring WITHIN a society, this is a subculture/counterculture being so viewed). Put another way, Ethnocentrism is the judging, assessing, evaluating a cultural variation (or entire culture) that varies from us against the home culture’s standards. * Since Ethnocentrism is biased against one culture in favor of another (usually the home culture), the answers we arrive at are subjective and, therefore, limited how accurately, completely and thoroughly we have come to see and understand the culture and their variations. To get to a more objective understanding, we must get to Cultural Relativity. Going on with our CULTURE concepts … Ethnocentricity à Cultural Relativity * This is NOT a given as it takes conscious, concerted effort to move from ETHNOCENTRISM (subjectivity) to CULTURAL RELATIVITY (objectivity). Definition of Cultural Relativity The perspective that a foreign culture (or particular subculture or counterculture) should NOT be judged by the standards of a home culture (or, by the standards of the larger/dominant culture when occurring WITHIN a society), and that a behavior or way of thinking must be examined in its OWN cultural context. Put another way, Cultural Relativism is the process of taking into account differences across cultures without passing judgment or assigning value (from one to the other). Lastly … * The fact is, not all cultural variation is between entire societies/ cultures. Some of it clearly occurs between subsets of a single culture (within societies). Each “subset” of all the subsets within a particular culture is referred to as a SUBCULTURE. Therefore, each subculture may respond to another subculture within society with culture shock, ethnocentrism and will necessarily need to consciously get to Cultural Relativity in order to accurately, thoroughly and completely (answer for) and “see” and try to “understand” thru the cultural variation. In a slight variation on this, a given SUBCULTURE may view the larger CULTLURE with culture shock and ethnocentrism before doing the work to see them in a more culturally relative way and vice versa (the larger culture can do this to a particular subculture). ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ NOW, IT’S YOUR TIME TO DO APPLICATIONS EXAMPLES AND RESPONSES FROM YOU FOR APPLICATION # 2: CULTURE You could type in your responses and then cut down this doc to JUST the responses which start HERE before saving, then putting back into the ASSIGNMENT FOLDER. There are 15 for you to work through. ** You may need to COPY and PASTE a link I provide into a new window to get it to open for you. Name: _________________________________________________ Provide ONE example of a video clip OR article link found online for EACH of the FIVE cultural components and paste that link for each of the five. 1. Tools/ Technology: a. Provide to me an EXAMPLE that has the link/ clip à paste the link here: b. Describe what about it serves as an example for those people who have this item c. Cultural content is meant to help solve problems associated with living of the people that came up with and/or use it: What problem associated with living can is being helped/ solved with the item you listed? Very impressed. A modern man making very usable tools like our ancestors once did. I'm attempting a celt made of basalt. Catoctin greenstone. Was originally shooting for a 3/4 groove but the stone just kept saying celt, so going with the celt. Different type of handle now though. Was going with a pin oak for the 3/4 but will change to a handle design that will work for a celt. Hopefully the pin oak will still work. Will be sure the stone doesn't touch the sides. Will model it after the one you've made. By the power you use to fell the tree, it looks like you definitely have a great design worked out. On a side note, I love the way you shot the bow video, with repeated tries over and over until you got closer and closer to the target by feel. Thank you for sharing what you've learned. Really enjoying your videos. 2. Beliefs a. Provide to me an EXAMPLE that has the link/ clip à paste the link here: *** DO NOT USE RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AS YOUR EXAMPLE b. Describe what about it serves as an example for those people who have this item c. Cultural content is meant to help solve problems associated with living of the people that came up with and/or use it: What problem associated with living can is being helped/ solved with the item you listed? 3. Norms a. Provide to me an EXAMPLE that has the link/ clip à paste the link here: b. Describe what about it serves as an example for those people who have this item c. Cultural content is meant to help solve problems associated with living of the people that came up with and/or use it: What problem associated with living can is being helped/ solved with the item you listed? 4. Values a. Provide to me an EXAMPLE that has the link/ clip à paste the link here: b. Describe what about it serves as an example for those people who have this item c. Cultural content is meant to help solve problems associated with living of the people that came up with and/or use it: What problem associated with living can is being helped/ solved with the item you listed? 5. Language, Symbols, Communication a. Provide to me an EXAMPLE that has the link/ clip à paste the link here: b. Describe what about it serves as an example for those people who have this item c. Cultural content is meant to help solve problems associated with living of the people that came up with and/or use it: What problem associated with living can is being helped/ solved with the item you listed? MORE ON NEXT PAGE … Moving into the next Culture related concepts … CULTURE SHOCK/ ETHNOCENTRISM: For the following … Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for each. Note: You may be shocked (or not at all). You may witness in a clip someone else being shocked (or not at all). “Shocked” is NOT the same as CULTURE SHOCK. Note: You may be absolutely fine with what you see in any of these clips or you may be slightly to largely put off by it. Even if you are not, walk in the shoes of those who might be and so may experience CULTURE SHOCK and ETHNOCENTRISM and speak about that or even your own, not just tell me “it’s all good” or “it’s somehow quite bad”. Tell me how the CONCEPTS apply even if to you. Note: I realize you may stand with the person in the article or against them. That is not the point unless you make it the point. The point is whoever stands in different positions may allow for ETHNOCENTRISM and make CULTURAL RELATIVITY a harder step to get to in analyzing what is happening. So again, you must look at you or who is in the video and show me you can “see” the concept and apply THAT for me. 6. Food![https://mail.anokaramsey.edu/owa/14.3.181.6/themes/resources/clear1x1.gif]() as Cultural Expression Clip a: Bizarre Foods with Andrew Zimmern: Gulf Coast Eating of Nutria, Squirrel, Turducken, Possum and Racoon, etc. LINK to watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMVaHxU0ctA And … Clip b: Andrew Zimmern: Bizarre Foods with Andrew Zimmern: Minnesota Lutefisk, State Fair and more LINK to watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IHyY7fggY0 Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for each of these two clips: Clip a: Good lord, not every Jew keeps kosher! He's non-observant, meaning he only identifies with his Jewishness ethnically and culturally- he doesn't keep the ritual laws. Just like not all Christians practice Christianity or all Muslims practice Islam. He was born into the religion/ethnicity and that's about it. That doesn't make him a fraud. Clip b:It would do my heart good to see every person that identifies as Indian forced to live as their ancestors did before the white man came to this hemisphere. Mind you, we brought over the horses, so they would be afoot. The Navajo wouldn't have any sheep or wool blankets 7.Ethnicity and Ethnic Characteristics Ahmed and other kids Bring a Homemade clocks to school Clip a: LINK: http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/09/16/440820557/high-school-student-shows-off-homemade-clock-gets-handcuffed Clip b: LINK: http://gawker.com/7-kids-not-named-mohamed-who-brought-homemade-clocks-to-1730999866 Clip c: LINK: http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-08-08/irving-school-district-sued-by-ahmed-mohamed-clock-boy-from-texas Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for three three clips: 8.Ethnicity and Ethnic Characteristics FedEx Fail “Mock” Advertisement ** Note that this is NOT a real advertisement, but one made by Native groups trying to raise awareness of FedEx’s relationship with the NFL Washington Redskins. LINK: http://youtu.be/0Xr-xNjIjcg Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for each: 9. Ethnicity and Ethnic Characteristics: Hair Navajo Child Asked to Cut Hair for School Dress Code Clip a: LINK: http://colorlines.com/archives/2014/08/navajo_kindergartener_told_to_cut_his_hair_sent_home_on_first_day_of_school.html Clip b: LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBr--m3B-Pw Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for these two clips: 10. Academics and Work Clip a: Professors are Prejudiced, Too (article, not video) LINK: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/11/opinion/sunday/professors-are-prejudiced-too.html?_r=0 Clip b: Buzzfeed: Changing Jose to Joe LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PR7SG2C7IVU Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for these two clips: 11. Out and About in Public Whose Bicycle is it? Race and Sex and stealing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ABRlWybBqM Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why for each: 12.Business and Media Coca Cola: Two clips Clip a. Coca Cola Superbowl advertisement, 2014 & 2017, & 2016 Olympics LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xYVu7tRXuoM Clip b. Coca Cola Superbowl ad 2014 STORY of the CONTROVERSY it stirred: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tURJfCDfk38 Clip c. Airbnb Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qUTYHnLz2g Clip d. 84 Lumber advertisement LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4p5n2kc-xDI Clip e. Budweiser advertisement LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZmlRtpzwos and … Briefly Discuss who (you or someone in the source or both) is shocked and ethnocentric and why across these FIVE ads … THEN DISCUSS what about these FIVE advertisement is meant to present CULTURAL RELATIVITY for these five clips: 13. Anti Muslim or Immigrant exposure: ethnocentrism and cultural relativity Clip a: Anti-Muslim Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FbWmBUONtFY Clip b: Anti-Immigrant Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNX1256eVw8 Provide ONE example from EACH of these TWO clips provided that shows ETHNOCENTRISM and ONE example from the clip provided that shows attempts to go beyond ethnocentrism to CULTURAL RELATIVITY. Example clip a: Anti Muslim exposure 1. Ethnocentrism – 2. Going beyond to Cultural Relativity -- Example clip b: Anti Immigrant exposure 1. Ethnocentrism – 2. Going beyond to Cultural Relativity -- 14. Describe ONE example from your own life of seeing/ perceiving some other individual or group with CULTURE SHOCK & ETHNOCENTRISM. Your Responses: 15. Cite ONE example of your own of BEING SEEN or PERCEIVED by others with CULTURE SHOCK & ETHNOCENTRISM. Your Responses: |